Owner proposalGuest servicesAsk AI about Rad Stayoperations@rad-stay.com1-877-723-7829
1-877-723-7829 Get a proposalProposal
Illustration of the restored facade of a late-1800s brick commercial building with arched windows
Management guides · Historic buildings

Managing a Historic Building in Nashville

Illustration

If your Nashville building is old enough to have a history, three separate systems may touch it: a Metro zoning overlay, a federal listing, and the federal rehabilitation tax credit. They are easy to confuse, and they do different things. This guide separates them, shows where they meet short-term rental permits and day-to-day management, and points to the office that must confirm each step.

Key facts
Local review body
Metro Historic Zoning Commission, which administers historic overlays
Federal listing
National Register of Historic Places, run by the National Park Service
Federal credit
20% of qualified rehabilitation expenditures, claimed over 5 years (26 U.S.C. 47)
Overlay and STR permits
Metro Code 17.36.100-.120 has no short-term rental rule for historic overlays
Example
Union Street Lofts, 329 Union Street, parcel zoned DTC with a historic overlay adopted in 2023
On this page
  1. Three different systems, one building
  2. Metro historic overlays and the Historic Zoning Commission
  3. What needs a preservation permit
  4. National Register listing
  5. The federal rehabilitation tax credit
  6. Who to ask about state programs
  7. Historic buildings and short-term rental permits
  8. A working example at 329 Union Street
  9. A management checklist for the owner
  10. Questions
  11. Sources

Three different systems, one building

Owners often say a building is historic and mean one of three things. The first is a local zoning overlay, which Metro adopts and the Metro Historic Zoning Commission administers. The second is a listing on the federal National Register, which the National Park Service keeps. The third is certification for the federal historic rehabilitation tax credit, run jointly by the Park Service, the IRS and the state's historic preservation office, which in Tennessee is the Tennessee Historical Commission.

A building can have one, two or all three. A listing does not by itself put Metro review on your windows, and a Metro overlay does not by itself make you eligible for a tax credit. Before you buy, price a renovation or write a management plan, find out which of the three apply to the exact parcel. Ask Metro Planning for the overlay status and ask the Tennessee Historical Commission about listing and credit eligibility.

Metro historic overlays and the Historic Zoning Commission

An overlay is a zoning district placed over the base zoning. In Metro's parcel data, 329 Union Street carries a DTC base zone and also a historic preservation overlay code, among other overlay codes.

Metro creates a historic overlay by ordinance. Ordinance BL2023-2053, passed by Metro Council on August 15, 2023 (effective September 1, 2023 in Metro's overlay layer), applied a Historic Preservation Overlay District to properties along 3rd and 4th Avenue North, southwest of Deaderick Street, zoned DTC, covering 4.18 acres under Proposal No. 2023HP-001-001. Metro's overlay layer carries the same ordinance number.

Overlays sit in Chapter 17.36, the historic ones numbered 17.36.100 to .120. Which guidelines govern your building depends on which overlay it sits in, so read the adopted design guidelines for that specific district rather than a general summary, and confirm current forms, fees and meeting dates with Metro Planning.

What needs a preservation permit

Whether a given job needs a historic preservation permit, and whether Metro staff or the Historic Zoning Commission decides it, is set by the adopted design guidelines for your district and by Metro Planning's forms. This guide does not list which scopes of work need a permit, so ask Metro Planning before you start.

A practical habit: write down every exterior job before you start, and send the list to Metro Planning historic staff with photos. Roofs, windows, masonry, storefronts, signs, mechanical equipment on the roof or facade, and anything visible from the street are the items to ask about. Ask in writing and keep the answer in the building file. A management company can do that for an absent owner, but the permit applicant is the owner.

National Register listing

The National Register is the federal list of places recognized for historic significance. State Historic Preservation Offices receive and review nominations, and the National Park Service administers the Register. Listing is largely honorary: it does not restrict what a private owner does with the property. Federal funding or a federal permit for a project triggers Section 106 review, and state or local laws can apply separately. The belief that a building must be 50 years old to be listed is a misconception; the 50-year mark is a criteria consideration for recent properties, not a hard rule.

Nominations go through the State Historic Preservation Office, which in Tennessee is the Tennessee Historical Commission. The state office reviews a nomination and the National Park Service approves or denies it. For a district, objections from a majority of owners block listing, and a private owner's objection can block listing of an individual property.

Downtown Nashville has a well-known example. The Printers Alley Historic District went on that list on August 26, 1982 (reference 82003964). Wikipedia puts it at about five acres on both sides of Church Street, bounded by Third Avenue, Fourth Avenue and Bank Alley, in Italianate, Queen Anne and Romanesque styles. It also notes the area became the city's printing hub around 1830, housed two big newspapers, 13 publishing houses and 10 print shops by 1915, and lost its last printer in 1977. Whether a particular parcel on Union Street is inside that district, or is a contributing building, is a question for the National Park Service record and the Tennessee Historical Commission, not for a guide like this one.

Why it matters to a manager: a listing as a historic district, or a determination that a building is eligible, is one of the paths to the tax credit below. The listing alone does not make the building eligible for Metro permits to be waived, and it does not change what Metro Code 6.28 requires of a short-term rental.

The federal rehabilitation tax credit

Section 47 of the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 47) sets the credit at 20% of qualified rehabilitation spending, claimed in equal parts over five years starting the year the building is placed in service. The building has to be a certified historic structure, meaning on the National Register in its own right, or certified by the Interior Secretary as contributing to a registered historic district.

The spending must be a substantial rehabilitation. Within a 24-month period of your choosing, qualified spending must be more than $5,000 or the adjusted basis, if that is larger; phased projects get 60 months. Qualified expenditures are capital costs for depreciable nonresidential real property or residential rental property. Acquisition costs and enlargements do not count, and work on a certified historic structure qualifies only as a certified rehabilitation. The expenditures generally must be depreciated straight-line.

Recapture is the part owners overlook. Under 26 U.S.C. 50(a), if the building stops qualifying in the first five years after it enters service, part of the credit is repaid as tax: all of it within the first full year, then 80%, 60%, 40% and 20% in years two through five. A sale inside that window can trigger it. The statute excludes transfers by reason of death and mere changes in the form of the business where the property stays in use and the taxpayer keeps a substantial interest, so ask a tax adviser how a planned change of ownership structure would be treated.

Section 47 sets four conditions for a qualified rehabilitated building. The building must be substantially rehabilitated, already in service before the work began, a certified historic structure, and depreciable or amortizable. Reconstruction counts as rehabilitation. A building that was not in service before the work began does not meet the second condition.

Three more exclusions matter to an owner who leases space. Expenditures for the part of the property that is, or is expected to be, tax-exempt use property are excluded. Lessee expenditures are excluded where the remaining lease term is shorter than the recovery period. And under 26 U.S.C. 50(c), the credit reduces the property's basis, and any recapture adds it back. These are the statute's rules as written, and a tax adviser has to apply them to the owner's facts.

The National Park Service says applications are submitted and reviewed electronically and must use forms dated Rev. 6/2023. The National Park Service says the program is administered by its Technical Preservation Services and the IRS in partnership with State Historic Preservation Offices, and the Tennessee Historical Commission lists a Federal Historic Tax Credit Program among its federal programs. Because the credit depends on the tax situation of the owner or partnership, it is a question for a tax adviser and the Tennessee Historical Commission, and the application should be started before the work begins.

Who to ask about state programs

The Tennessee Historical Commission is the state's State Historic Preservation Office, and its website lists a Federal Historic Tax Credit Program under Federal Programs. This guide does not state whether Tennessee offers any state-level credit or grant, because we could not confirm it from a current source. Ask the Commission before you count on one.

A manager can collect the paperwork and the contractor quotes for an absent owner. Design decisions on a protected facade belong to the owner's architect and the reviewing offices.

Historic buildings and short-term rental permits

An overlay does not decide whether a unit can be a short-term rental. Read as of June 23, 2026, the Metro Code's historic overlay text in Chapter 17.36 says nothing on nightly rental. Base zoning decides it. Section 6.28.030 lists, by name, the zones (business, office, mixed-use and downtown) where a new absent-owner permit can issue, with conditions, a group that takes in the North, Central, West and South areas of DTC but leaves out DTC East, and our permits guide linked below names them all. The one place an historic overlay does come up is for detached accessory dwelling units, which follow that overlay's guidelines under 17.16.030.G.9.

The permit rules that matter most in an older multi-unit building are the same ones that apply to any building. The code sets a maximum of four sleeping rooms per permit. Metro's checklist puts any building of three-plus dwellings in line for a Fire Marshal inspection. Applicants must notify every neighboring owner in writing, the floors above and below included. Each also certifies that no lease or other agreement on the property forbids renting.

Metro's operating rules apply to an old building just as to a new one. The holder needs a local contact for the property within 25 miles, reachable by day or night, along with liability insurance worth $1 million or more each occurrence. Stays may not pass 30 consecutive nights, and the lead renter's minimum age is 21. Metro also withholds new permits inside 100 feet of a church, park, school, school playground or licensed day care center, save by Council waiver. Confirm each of these with Metro Codes before you apply.

Two permit rules are especially important when an older building changes hands. Permits cannot be assigned, and a change of owner voids them, so the buyer must reapply under whatever rules then apply. Metro's operation page says that deeding the building from a person to a trust or LLC is such a change. Permits last twelve months, and renewal reminders arrive two months ahead and again at 45 days. If you are buying a historic building because it already has permits, confirm with Metro Codes what the sale does to them before you close.

A working example at 329 Union Street

Rad Stay's Union Street Lofts are four short-term lofts on the second floor of number 329, on the Printers Alley block. Metro's open data shows the parcel zoned DTC, with two brick structures recorded as built in 1890 and 1935. Metro's overlay layer places the address inside a historic preservation district overlay adopted in 2023 under ordinance BL2023-2053. Metro's permit records show four not-owner-occupied permits for Units 201 through 204, issued in April 2023.

What that means for daily management is modest. Exterior changes to a building like this go to Metro Planning historic staff first. Every listing shows its unit's permit number, and each permit must be renewed yearly. The overlay concerns what can change on the outside of the building; the permits, the Fire Marshal rules and the guest rules in Chapter 6.28 govern how the lofts operate.

A management checklist for the owner

These steps fit any older Nashville apartment building. None of them is legal, tax or investment advice.

  • Get the overlay status of the parcel from Metro Planning, in writing, and download the adopted design guidelines for that district.
  • Ask the Tennessee Historical Commission whether the building is listed, in a listed district, or eligible, before you spend on any rehabilitation you hope to claim a credit for.
  • Keep a dated photo record of the exterior before any work, and a file of every permit and approval.
  • Send every exterior job to Metro Planning historic staff before the contractor is hired.
  • If units are or will be rented nightly, confirm zoning eligibility, the Fire Marshal visit, and what a sale would do to the permits.
  • Track each unit's permit expiry and renewal on one sheet.

Questions

Does being in a Metro historic overlay stop me from running short-term rentals?

Sections 17.36.100 to .120, the historic overlay sections, do not address nightly rental at all; the base zoning, read with Section 6.28.030, settles it, so check your parcel with Metro Codes.

Does National Register listing limit what I can do with my building?

Listing does not by itself restrict a private owner's use of the property. Federally funded or federally permitted projects trigger Section 106 review, and state or local laws, such as a Metro overlay, may apply separately.

How big is the federal historic tax credit?

26 U.S.C. 47 sets it at 20% of qualified rehabilitation expenditures, taken over five years, for a certified historic structure that undergoes a substantial rehabilitation. Acquisition costs do not count. Ask a tax adviser and the Tennessee Historical Commission whether your project qualifies.

What happens to the credit if I sell soon after finishing the work?

Under 26 U.S.C. 50(a), a disposition inside five years recaptures part of the credit: 100% in the first full year, then 80%, 60%, 40% and 20% in years two through five.

If I sell the building, does the permit go with it?

No. They do not; Metro lets no permit be transferred or assigned, so a buyer has to apply afresh under the rules in force. Confirm with Metro Codes before closing.

Top image: Illustration of a representative scene, not a specific property.

To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.

More management guides

All 4