1031 Exchanges and Rental Property
A 1031 exchange lets an owner sell real property held for investment or business use and put the proceeds into other real property without paying tax on the gain that year. The gain is postponed, not erased, and the rules on timing, money and who may help are strict. This page explains how the rules apply to Nashville rental buildings and where a short-term rental adds its own complications. Read it as background only; a CPA and a qualified intermediary should shape any exchange before you list or take an offer.
- Property that qualifies
- Real property only, since Jan. 1, 2018
- Identify replacement
- Within 45 days of transferring the old property
- Receive replacement
- Within 180 days, or the tax return due date with extensions if earlier
- Report on
- IRS Form 8824, with the return for the year of the exchange
- Tennessee transfer tax
- 37 cents per $100 of consideration or value, whichever is greater
On this page
- What the exchange does
- What counts as like-kind
- Furnishings in a furnished rental
- The 45-day and 180-day clocks
- How to identify replacement property
- The intermediary and who cannot be one
- Cash, debt and related parties
- Rentals you also use yourself
- The Nashville permit problem
- Tennessee closing costs on both sides
- Working with Rad Stay on an exchange
- Questions
- Sources
What the exchange does
Section 1031 lets you swap real property used in a business or held as an investment for other real property of like kind and defer the gain. The IRS describes the deferral plainly in its 2008 fact sheet on exchanges, now marked historical: gain is deferred, but not forgiven. Your basis in the old building generally carries into the new one, which leaves less to depreciate than a taxable purchase would and keeps the deferred gain in place until a later taxable sale.
Receiving cash or other property that is not like-kind does not cancel the exchange, but the Form 8824 instructions say gain is recognized up to the amount of that money and other property. A loss is never recognized in an exchange.
What counts as like-kind
Since January 1, 2018, only real property qualifies. The IRS's real estate tax tips page says real properties are generally like-kind whether improved or unimproved, so a Nashville fourplex can be exchanged for a warehouse, an apartment building or raw land, as long as each is held for business or investment. Two limits apply: property held primarily for sale does not qualify, and real property in the United States is not like-kind to real property abroad.
Stock, notes and partnership interests generally are not real property. The Form 8824 instructions list a few kinds of stock that count as real property, such as stock in a cooperative housing corporation.
Furnishings in a furnished rental
A short-term rental sells with beds, sofas, linens, televisions and kitchenware, and none of that is real property. Since 2018 furnishings cannot be exchanged under Section 1031. Treasury Regulation 1.1031(k)-1 treats personal property that is normally transferred with real property, and worth no more than 15 percent of it, as incidental: it needs no separate identification, and the Form 8824 instructions say it is ignored when testing whether your access to money held by an intermediary is properly limited.
That allowance concerns the mechanics of the exchange, not whether furniture becomes like-kind. Put a separate value on furnishings in both the sale contract and the purchase contract, and ask your CPA how each is taxed.
The 45-day and 180-day clocks
Both clocks start the day you transfer the property you are giving up. The replacement must be identified within 45 days and received within 180 days, or by the due date of your return for that year, counting extensions, if that date comes first. A replacement received within the first 45 days counts as identified automatically. The IRS's fact sheet says the periods generally cannot be extended except for presidentially declared disasters.
On a calendar: a sale that closes November 20, 2026 puts day 45 on January 4, 2027 and day 180 on May 19, 2027. Because the tax return for 2026 can come due before day 180, ask your CPA about extending the return so the full window stays open.
How to identify replacement property
The identification must be in writing, signed by you, and delivered within the 45 days to the seller of the replacement property or to another party to the exchange who is not a disqualified person; a written exchange agreement signed by all parties also works. Notice to your own attorney or agent is not enough. Describe each property by legal description, street address or a distinguishable name.
Treasury Regulation 1.1031(k)-1 limits how many properties you may name. You may name any three regardless of value, or any number whose combined value is no more than 200 percent of what you sold, or more than that only if you then acquire at least 95 percent of the value you named. Name too many and the regulation treats you as having named none. An identification can be revoked before day 45 by a signed written notice delivered the same way.
The intermediary and who cannot be one
In most exchanges the sale proceeds go to a qualified intermediary, not to you. The IRS fact sheet warns that taking control of the cash before the exchange is complete may disqualify the whole transaction. The regulation treats the intermediary as not being your agent only if your written agreement with it expressly limits your right to receive or benefit from the money it holds.
Some people cannot serve. The regulation disqualifies anyone who acted as your employee, attorney, accountant, investment banker or broker, or real estate agent or broker within the two years before the first transfer, along with parties related to you or to them by a 10 percent ownership link. Routine title insurance, escrow and bank services do not count, and neither does earlier work on your past exchanges.
Pick the intermediary with care. The IRS has warned that some intermediaries went bankrupt or failed to perform, leaving taxpayers past their deadlines, and the Form 8824 instructions point to Revenue Procedure 2010-14 for that situation.
Cash, debt and related parties
Taxable gain can appear without a check changing hands. The Form 8824 instructions count cash received, the fair market value of other property received and net liabilities the other side takes over, reduced by exchange expenses. Selling a building with a $900,000 loan and buying one with a $600,000 loan can leave up to the $300,000 difference taxable unless something offsets it; your CPA runs those numbers before you sign.
Exchanges with relatives or related entities carry a two-year rule. If either side disposes of what it received within two years of the last transfer, the deferred gain generally becomes reportable in that year, with exceptions for death, involuntary conversion and transactions without tax avoidance as a main purpose. Related-party exchanges are reported on Form 8824 for the exchange year and the two years after.
Rentals you also use yourself
Revenue Procedure 2008-16 gives a safe harbor for a dwelling unit such as a vacation home or condo. The IRS will not challenge whether the unit was held for investment or business use when you owned it for the 24 months before the exchange and, in each of those two years, rented it at a fair rent for 14 days or more while keeping your own use to no more than 14 days or one tenth of the fair-rental days, whichever number is larger. The same tests apply to a replacement unit for the 24 months after.
The procedure counts personal use the way Section 280A(d)(2) of the tax code does, so ask your CPA which days qualify. Your own nights at a Nashville rental count toward the limit.
The Nashville permit problem
Metro permits do not travel with a sale. Under a November 2024 amendment to Metro's code, a change in ownership under state law ends the permit, and the buyer must qualify under the code in force on the day it applies. If your replacement property is meant to be a short-term rental, its value to you rests on winning that application, and 45 days leaves little time to learn the answer.
Do the permit work before the clock starts. Build a list of candidate buildings whose zoning still accepts investor permits, check each parcel against Metro's 100-foot distance rule, and read any condo declaration or HOA rules. Name only buildings that pass. A building that fails the permit test after closing can still be held for investment as a longer-term rental; ask your CPA and intermediary whether that changes anything for the exchange.
Tennessee closing costs on both sides
An exchange is two closings, and Tennessee taxes each recorded transfer. The Department of Revenue's REC-1 article sets the realty transfer tax at 37 cents per $100, generally on the greater of the price or the property's value, and a separate indebtedness tax of 11.5 cents per $100 on a recorded mortgage, after the first $2,000. A $1.5 million replacement bought with a $1 million loan carries about $5,550 in transfer tax and about $1,148 in indebtedness tax.
Property tax also resets with the new parcel. Tennessee assesses residential parcels at a quarter of appraised value and commercial ones at two fifths, and state law has its own tests for how a parcel used for short-term rental is classified, so ask the Davidson County Assessor how the replacement is classed before you underwrite it. If you hold property in an LLC or corporation, Tennessee's franchise and excise taxes generally apply to the entity unless it qualifies for an exemption; ask your CPA how an exchange is treated for them.
Working with Rad Stay on an exchange
Besides managing for owners, Rad Stay looks at some buildings as a possible buyer, tenant or partner. If you are selling a building and plan an exchange, tell every buyer early, Rad Stay included, so the contract carries the assignment and cooperation wording your intermediary asks for. If you are buying a replacement in Nashville, Rad Stay can review the candidate list against the permit rules inside your 45 days. An ordinary master lease to an operator is not a sale, so it starts no exchange clock; ask your intermediary before treating any long lease as part of an exchange.
Union Street Lofts, four short-term rental lofts at 329 Union Street in the Printers Alley block, run by Rad Stay since 2023.
- 4.98average rating across 214 Airbnb reviews of the four lofts
- Guest Favoritebadges on the lofts' Airbnb listings, with Superhost status
- 4 of 4lofts hold Metro non-owner-occupied permits, issued April 2023
- WKRN News 2segment on the lofts, published June 11, 2026
Airbnb figures from the four listings as read October 4, 2026. Permits from Metro Codes. Read the case study · See the portfolio
Questions
Can I exchange a long-term rental for a short-term rental?
Generally yes. Both are real estate held to earn income, which makes them like-kind. Whether the new building can get a Nashville permit is a separate question to settle before you identify it.
Can my real estate agent or accountant hold the money?
Not if they worked for you in that role in the two years before the first transfer. The regulation treats them as disqualified, apart from routine title, escrow and bank services.
Do the furniture and supplies count?
No. Since 2018 only real property qualifies. Value furnishings separately in both contracts and ask your CPA how they are taxed.
What if I cannot close on any property I identified?
Then the exchange fails and the sale is generally taxable for the year it closed. That is why many sellers name three properties and line up financing before they list.
Can I stay in the replacement property myself?
Only a little if you want the IRS safe harbor: in each of the two years after the exchange, rent it at a fair rent for 14 days or more and keep your own use to no more than the larger of 14 days or a tenth of the rented days.
Where do I report the exchange?
On Form 8824, filed with your return for the year of the exchange, and for related-party exchanges in each of the two following years too.
Sources
- IRS, Like-kind exchanges: real estate tax tips
- IRS, Instructions for Form 8824 (2025)
- IRS Fact Sheet FS-2008-18, Like-Kind Exchanges Under IRC Section 1031 (Feb. 2008, historical)
- 26 CFR 1.1031(k)-1, Treatment of deferred exchanges (Cornell LII)
- IRS Revenue Procedure 2008-16
- Metro Codes, Operation Rules and Requirements (Wayback copy Feb. 12, 2026)
- Metro Codes, Permit Types (Wayback copy Feb. 17, 2026)
- Tennessee Department of Revenue, REC-1 Recordation Tax Overview (Wayback copy Aug. 7, 2025)
- Metropolitan Trustee, How to Figure Your Property Tax Bill (Wayback copy Oct. 22, 2026)
- Tenn. Code Ann. 67-5-801, FindLaw copy current as of Jan. 2, 2024
- Tennessee Department of Revenue, Franchise and Excise Tax (read Nov. 12, 2026)
- Metro Council Legistar, BL2024-478 amending Chapter 6.28 (final passage Nov. 7, 2024; text read Nov. 12, 2026)
Checked November 12, 2026.
To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.
More acquisitions
All 15Buying a Short-Term Rental in Nashville
When you buy a Nashville property to run as a short-term rental, you are not buying the seller's permit.
Due Diligence Checklist for an STR Property
Due diligence is what a buyer checks between signing a contract and closing: the permit record, the zoning, the building, the books and the paperwork behind them.
How STR Properties Are Valued
A short-term rental building in Nashville is worth what a buyer believes it can earn after the sale, and that is often a different number from what it earns for you today.









