Managing Four Units in One Historic Building
An older Nashville building cut into four rentals answers to two rulebooks at once: whatever historic designation covers the structure, and the short-term rental code that governs each apartment separately. Here we take the historic side first, then the rental side, then the daily work, using Union Street Lofts as the working example for the operating questions.
- Example building
- Union Street Lofts, Units 201 to 204, 329 Union Street
- Permits
- Four, one per loft, not owner-occupied, issued April 2023
- Airbnb, Nov. 12, 2026
- 217 reviews, 4.97 average; host Kasra is a Superhost
- Fire code Metro enforces
- 2024 IFC and 2024 NFPA 101 (BL2025-1004)
- Federal rehabilitation credit
- 20% of qualified expenses, income-producing buildings
- Taxes on each night
- 9.75% sales tax, 7% occupancy tax, plus a per-night charge
On this page
- Three meanings of historic in Nashville
- What federal listing does and does not do
- When a Metro overlay applies
- Demolition and the evidence Metro asks for
- Historic status and rental eligibility
- The 20% federal credit
- Four apartments, four permits
- Fire inspection for a building with several homes
- Holding title in the right name
- One desk for four units
- Calendars, turnovers and an old building's quirks
- Taxes and renewal dates
- What the lofts' record shows
- Questions
- Sources
Three meanings of historic in Nashville
Owners use the word for three different situations, and only two of them come with rules. A building may be on the federal list kept by the National Park Service, on its own or as part of a listed district. It may stand inside a Metro historic zoning overlay, which a local commission reviews. Or it may just be old, with no designation of any kind.
Which of the three applies decides the paperwork for a new roof, a window swap or a second exit stair, so settle it before you plan any work. For overlays, Metro's parcel viewer or a call to the Historic Zoning Commission's staff gives the answer for one address. For federal listing, the Park Service's own records are the place to look.
What federal listing does and does not do
The Park Service is direct about this: a spot on its list puts no limits on a private owner's choices for the property, demolition included, so long as no federal money is involved. Once a project uses federal assistance, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation must be given a chance to weigh in on the changes. The Park Service adds that state or local preservation laws may still reach the same building, and that the Register itself never charges a fee, so a letter demanding one is a scam.
Two listed districts meet on the blocks around Union Street Lofts. Printers Alley's district went on the list on August 26, 1982, and takes in roughly five acres between Third and Fourth avenues, from Bank Alley down to and across Church Street. Listed March 20, 2002, the Nashville Financial Historic District is tiny by comparison: under an acre, five adjoining bank buildings. Its nomination draws the edges at Union Street to the north and Printers Alley to the west, and the bank lots fronting 3rd Avenue close it on the east. The lofts' address falls outside both, and we do not publish a construction date for the building.
When a Metro overlay applies
Local overlays are where historic status changes what you may build. Inside one, work on a property goes through the commission for a preservation permit. Projects that are pre-approved and meet the design guidelines generally get one from staff within four days; infill, large additions and demolition of a main historic building usually go before the full commission. Staff issues the permit once the commission approves, and the owner hands it to the building department to finish the building permit. The plans filed at the two offices have to match, and Metro warns that submitting different plans gets the preservation permit rescinded.
Applications that go before the full commission carry a notice duty for the applicant, with yard signs and letters. Talking with staff before applying is optional, but Metro encourages it for infill, additions with footprints over 1,500 square feet, unusual requests, and any job that also needs a Land Development application, and it notes that plans cannot be revised once a complete application is in at the deadline.
Demolition and the evidence Metro asks for
Taking down a building in an overlay is the hardest request to win, and Metro's application spells out what the commission wants to see. It asks whether the property could earn a reasonable economic return as it stands, for any inspection reports done before a purchase made within the last 12 months, and for proof that real attempts at reuse were made, such as applying for rehabilitation incentives or working with staff on new construction that would make a rehab pencil out. Experts who supply that information are asked to show their background with historic buildings.
For a four-unit building the lesson runs the other way. If an older structure might someday be worth more as a teardown, find out its overlay status before you buy, since a preservation overlay can take that option off the table.
Historic status and rental eligibility
A historic overlay does not, by itself, open or close the door to short-term renting. Our reading of Metro's overlay chapter, 17.36, found that its historic districts say nothing about rentals; the one rental clause in that chapter deals with detached accessory units. Eligibility still turns on the base zoning district and, for investor permits, the distance test. The overlay governs what the outside of the building looks like, not who sleeps inside it.
The 20% federal credit
For a building that qualifies, the federal rehabilitation credit is worth 20% of the qualified expenses of the work, according to the Park Service. Four conditions come with it. The Park Service has to certify the building as historic, the building has to be used to produce income, a substantial sum has to go into the rehabilitation, and the work has to satisfy the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, which the Park Service applies.
The Park Service's approval covers the preservation side only; the tax treatment is the IRS's call. Whether units rented by the night count the same way as apartments rented by the year belongs with a tax professional before the first contractor is hired. Application forms come from the state's historic preservation office.
Four apartments, four permits
Nashville issues no single rental permit for a whole building. Every apartment that hosts guests for under a month needs its own, and Metro refuses any home with more than four bedrooms. At Union Street Lofts that means four separate investor permits, one each for Units 201 through 204, all dated April 2023.
The practical consequence is bookkeeping. Each loft has its own guest cap tied to its bedroom count, its own contact notice on the wall, and its own permit number that has to appear on every listing for that loft. Keep a one-page sheet per unit with the permit number, issue date, guest limit and the link to each live listing, and check it any time a listing is edited. The full list of operating rules is on the multifamily permits guide linked below.
Fire inspection for a building with several homes
Metro's checklist sends the Fire Marshal to any parcel holding three or more homes; for a lone house or duplex, a state-licensed architect, engineer or home inspector certifies instead. Four lofts put a building in the inspected group.
The code behind that inspection is new. BL2025-1004, approved by the Mayor on October 10, 2025, put the International Fire Code's 2024 edition in force locally, together with NFPA's 2024 Life Safety Code. It also sends any existing-building question left open by the fire code over to the Life Safety Code, which is the part an older building is most likely to meet, and it lets the fire official accept newer editions as proof of compliance. Before rebuilding a stair, corridor or exit, get the Fire Marshal's Office to name the edition and chapter your building will be held to.
Holding title in the right name
Since BL2024-478, permits end when the owner changes, and Metro treats deeding a property between a person and a company or trust as that kind of change. For four units, a transfer into an LLC for liability reasons would end four permits in one signature, and each unit would have to apply again under that day's code.
Metro's own explainer says an LLC that already holds permits can change members without disturbing them. So the order of steps matters: pick the ownership structure, then apply. Talk to a Tennessee real estate attorney before you record any deed on a permitted building.
One desk for four units
Each of the four permits carries a nearby responsible party, and that line has to be picked up day or night for as long as guests are staying. With four units, run that from a single desk with one written building guide: the breaker panel's location, how the street door works, who services the roof and the HVAC, and what to tell a guest on a loud night.
The lofts' own reviews show why the desk matters. In the 281 written reviews we saved in October 2026, 139 bring up the host or the speed of replies, more than mention cleaning or decor. Metro's code also wants a six-month guest register, and the desk that answers the phone is the natural keeper of it for all four units.
Calendars, turnovers and an old building's quirks
Four units on several booking sites means a dozen or more calendars to keep in step, and one missed sync sells a night twice. Pick one system as the record for each loft and compare it with every channel weekly. Guests have reviewed the lofts on four platforms, Google among them, a reminder of how many places a single building is seen.
Turnovers bunch in a building, because several units often empty on one morning; schedule cleaners for the building and give them a checklist per unit. Older buildings add their own lines to that list. The lofts are upstairs, 18 of the written reviews mention stairs, and 45 say something about noise or quiet, so the listings should give the stair count and describe weekend noise plainly.
Taxes and renewal dates
Every rented night owes three things: sales tax at Davidson County's 9.75%, Metro's 7% occupancy tax, and the flat Metro charge on each room-night. The occupancy return goes to Metro's Collections Office monthly, by the 20th. A platform that remits tax does so for its own reservations and the taxes it lists; direct stays remain yours to report. This is background only, not tax advice.
Each permit runs 365 days. Codes sends two reminder emails, the first at 60 days and the second at 45. Its FAQ prices a renewal at $313 and asks for two proofs, one of current insurance and one of paid hotel occupancy tax. When four units were permitted together, as the lofts were, their renewals land in the same weeks, so run them as one job. Metro may grant extra days after expiry to a permit with a clean record, at its discretion only, so file early.
What the lofts' record shows
On November 12, 2026, the four listings on Airbnb carried 217 reviews with a 4.97 average, and their host, Kasra, held Superhost status. That record is public, and anyone weighing a similar building can read the full set of reviews before deciding how to run their own. Our October topic count found the location raised in more than half of the written reviews and cleaning in nearly a third.
None of that predicts results for another building. What carries over is the order of work: find the historic layer, permit each apartment separately, clear the fire inspection, settle the ownership name before applying, and run every unit from one desk with one set of checklists.
Questions
Is 329 Union Street in a historic district?
It sits outside both federally listed districts beside it, the Nashville Financial district and Printers Alley. We do not publish a construction year for the building.
Does federal listing stop an owner from renovating?
No. The Park Service says listing puts no limits on a private owner spending private money. Metro's historic overlays are different, since exterior work inside one needs a preservation permit.
Can a historic overlay rule out renting a unit by the night?
Not by itself. The overlay chapter's historic sections are silent on rentals, so the base district and the distance test decide. The overlay controls exterior changes.
Can one permit cover all four units?
No. Every apartment needs its own permit, with its own guest cap and its own number to display in each listing.
Will the Fire Marshal inspect a four-unit building?
Yes. Metro's checklist sends properties with three or more homes to the Fire Marshal, and the 2024 fire and life safety codes adopted by BL2025-1004 are the standard.
Sources
- National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places FAQs
- Wikipedia, Printers Alley Historic District
- Wikipedia, Nashville Financial Historic District
- National Park Service, NRIS 02000232, Nashville Financial Historic District
- Metro Planning, Apply for Historic Preservation Permit (Wayback copy, Oct. 22, 2026; page updated Aug. 14, 2026)
- National Park Service, Tax Credit Basics
- Metro Code chapter 6.28 and chapter 17.36 (Municode, version of June 23, 2026)
- Metro Codes, Not Owner Occupied Checklist (Wayback copy, Feb. 16, 2026)
- Metro Codes, Apply for a Short Term Rental Property Permit (Wayback copy, Aug. 22, 2026)
- Metro Codes, Operation Requirements (Wayback copy, Feb. 12, 2026)
- Metro Codes, Renew a Short Term Rental Property Permit (Wayback copy, Oct. 12, 2026)
- Metro Council, BL2025-1004, 2024 International Fire Code and NFPA 101 (Legistar)
- Metro Council, BL2024-478 (Legistar)
- Metro Finance, Pay Short Term Rental Property Occupancy Tax (Wayback copy, Oct. 22, 2026)
- Metro Nashville Residential Short Term Rental Permits (open data), status Issued, retrieved November 3, 2026
- Airbnb, host profile for the four Union Street Lofts listings (read Nov. 12, 2026)
- National Park Service, NRHP nomination, Nashville Financial Historic District (boundary and resource count)
- National Park Service, NRIS 82003964, Printers Alley Historic District
- Metro Codes, Short Term Rental FAQ (Wayback copy, Oct. 22, 2026)
Checked November 12, 2026.
To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.
More blog
All 10What the New Stadium Could Mean for East Bank Rentals
The Titans' enclosed stadium across the river from downtown is due to be finished in February 2027, and its first booked events are already on the calendar.
A Nashville Owner's Calendar for 2027
This is the 2027 calendar as it stood on November 12, 2026: the events with published dates, the federal holidays that make long weekends, and the filing and payment dates that come with owning a permitted rental.
What 7,000 Issued STR Permits Say About Nashville
In our November 3, 2026 download, Metro's open permit file held 6,996 rental permits in ISSUED status.









