Owner proposalGuest servicesAsk AI about Rad Stayoperations@rad-stay.com1-877-723-7829
1-877-723-7829 Get a proposalProposal
Illustration of a desk with a calculator, a pencil and a closed laptop by a window over brick rooftops
Investment guide · Method and dated benchmarks

Underwriting a Short-Term Rental Building

Illustration

Underwriting a short-term rental building means turning a unit count into a revenue line, then taking out everything that sits between the guest's payment and your net operating income. In Nashville the first step is the permit, because the income depends on it and it does not transfer to a buyer. This guide gives the method and the dated public numbers to test it against.

Key facts
Permit unit
Each dwelling unit, up to four sleeping rooms
Issued STR permits, Davidson County
7,022 (Oct. 6, 2026)
Hotel occupancy, Davidson County, 2025
67.0%
Hotel average daily rate, 2025
$199.20
Sales tax on a Nashville stay
9.75% (7% state + 2.75% Davidson County, since Feb. 1, 2025)
Metro hotel occupancy tax
7% plus a flat nightly charge, $2.50 per room on Metro's posted return
On this page
  1. Start with the permit
  2. A permit does not come with the building
  3. Build revenue from units, nights and rate
  4. Two sensitivities worth running
  5. Public Nashville benchmarks
  6. Seasonality and event nights
  7. Platform and management fees
  8. Taxes on the guest's bill
  9. Taxes and licenses on the owner
  10. Costs that come with the permit
  11. Reserves and the lines NOI leaves out
  12. Stress tests before you bid
  13. Questions
  14. Sources

Start with the permit

Metro permits short-term rental unit by unit, never by building. Metro has no whole-building permit of either type, so each unit planned for nightly guests needs its own. Four sleeping rooms is a unit's maximum, and its guest limit is double its sleeping rooms plus four. The unit count you underwrite is the count you can permit, and no more.

Eligibility for new absent-owner permits depends on the district, and our multifamily permits guide lists those that qualify. DTC East and residential zoning are excluded. Nearby churches, schools, parks and licensed day cares, inside 100 feet, also block a new permit, absent a Council waiver.

Sort the units into three groups before you build any spreadsheet: units with a permit in good standing, units that could get one under today's zoning and distance rules, and units that cannot. Underwrite the third group on monthly or yearly lease income.

A permit does not come with the building

The permit cannot be assigned or transferred under 6.28.030. Permits end on a sale, so the buyer reapplies. Per Metro's operation requirements page, retitling the building to or from an LLC or trust has the same effect. A seller's history shows that guests wanted the units. It does not show that you will be allowed to rent them.

For scale, the open data held 7,022 issued permits on Oct. 6, 2026, of which 5,010 were not-owner-occupied and 2,012 owner-occupied. ZIP 37203 had more absent-owner permits than any other, 1,617. Those counts show where operators already compete for guests. The counts cannot tell you whether your parcel qualifies. Have Metro Codes confirm zoning, distance and any plan limits before you price the deal.

Build revenue from units, nights and rate

Build revenue from the bottom. For each unit type, multiply the nights available by occupancy by average daily rate, then add the cleaning fee you charge per stay. Group units by bedroom count, because the guest limit follows the sleeping rooms: a two-bedroom unit tops out at 8 guests and a three-bedroom at 10 under the code's formula. Three habits keep the model honest.

  • Cap every stay at 30 consecutive days. A permitted stay is one day to 30 nights long, and anything past that is a lease the permit does not cover.
  • Use payout, not the listing price. Platform statements show what you were actually paid after fees.
  • Keep new or newly permitted units out of the stabilized column until they have a booking history of their own.

Two sensitivities worth running

Small changes in occupancy and rate move a building's income more than most owners expect. Take a 20-unit building. It has 7,300 unit-nights available a year. One point of occupancy is 73 nights, and at a $200 average rate that is $14,600 in gross revenue. A $10 change in the average rate at 65% occupancy is 4,745 occupied nights times $10, or $47,450. These figures are arithmetic on assumed inputs, not a forecast for any building, and they show why the rate and occupancy assumptions deserve the most scrutiny in your model.

Public Nashville benchmarks

Citing STR, Visit Music City reports 67.0% hotel occupancy countywide for 2025 and an average daily rate of $199.20. The rate was down 1.3% from 2024, revenue per available room was down 2.1%, room demand rose 2.6%, and room supply grew 3.4%. Matthews, using CoStar data, reported that 524 hotel rooms opened in the third quarter of 2025 and 2,587 were under construction, equal to 4.2% of existing supply. In that quarter occupancy fell 2.8%, the average rate fell 1.4% and RevPAR fell 4.2%. Matthews linked the softness to new mid-tier supply, softer weekday business, lighter group travel and quieter weekend leisure demand.

These are hotel figures, not short-term rental figures. Use them as a cross-check on direction and on the price a guest sees at the hotel next door, not as an input to your rate. AirDNA publishes Nashville short-term rental figures, and this guide quotes none of them. Pull the current AirDNA market page or a paid report yourself, and write the date next to every number you take from it. Then replace all of it with comparable units in your own submarket.

Seasonality and event nights

The annual hotel average hides sharp peaks. Visit Music City's summer 2026 release reports July 4, 2026 at 74.6% occupancy countywide and 92.5% downtown. Alan Jackson's final concert at Nissan Stadium put hotels at 92% countywide and 98% downtown. Bruno Mars on May 6, 2026 produced 90% and 98%. Chris Stapleton and Lainey Wilson on May 23, 2026 produced 89% and 96.5%. CMA Fest 2026 (June 4 to 7) averaged 89.4% downtown. Against a 67.0% annual county average for 2025, those nights can price very differently from an ordinary Tuesday.

Model the calendar in three buckets rather than one monthly average: event nights, ordinary weekends and ordinary weeknights. Give each bucket its own occupancy and rate for each month. Treat weeknights as the soft spot, since Matthews named softer weekday business in 2025. Do not build a base case on a one-time event such as a farewell concert. Put the repeating events in the base case, put the one-offs in an upside column, and ask the seller for last year's rate and occupancy on the same dates so you can see what the building actually did on them.

Platform and management fees

Airbnb's help center says most hosts pay a single host-only service fee of 15.5% deducted from the payout, that remaining hosts typically pay 14% to 16%, and that a split-fee structure paid mostly at 3% is being phased out. Model the fee on the same revenue base the platform uses, and run the high end of the range as a test.

Management fees are a contract term, so get the quote in writing and model it as a separate line. Ask what the percentage applies to: nightly rate only, nightly rate plus cleaning fee, before or after platform fees. Ask which costs are billed on top: cleaning, linens, supplies, maintenance calls, photography, onboarding. Two quotes with the same percentage can produce different dollar amounts on the same booking. Cleaning belongs in its own line, built from the cost per turnover times the number of stays, which is nights divided by average stay length.

Taxes on the guest's bill

Stays shorter than 90 consecutive days owe Tennessee sales tax at 7% for the state plus Davidson County's local share. Voters in the county backed a transit surcharge of half a cent in November 2024, and when it took effect at the start of February 2025 the local share rose by half a point to 2.75%, up from 2.25% (Department of Revenue Notice 24-11). A guest in Nashville now pays 9.75% in sales tax. Per Notice 17-24, required cleaning and damage protection fees are part of the taxable price. Metro's hotel occupancy tax is separate. Metro's occupancy tax is 7%, made up of 6% under 5.12.020 and 1% for the Sports Authority under 5.12.150. Section 5.12.120 puts a further tax on each room and night, which Metro's posted return form lists at $2.50: $2.00 for the convention center and 50 cents for tourism events. The code ended that 50 cents on May 21, 2026, and BL2026-1493, approved September 4, 2026, moves the end to May 2032 once its debt condition is met, so underwrite at $2.50 and ask Metro Collections which amount it wants on each return.

Here is the stack on an assumed one-night stay priced at $250 including fees. Applying 9.75% to $250 gives $24.375, which rounds to $24.38 of sales tax. Occupancy tax is 7% of $250, or $17.50, plus $2.50 for the night, for $20.00. The guest pays $24.38 + $20.00 = $44.38 on top of the $250, which is 17.75% of the stay price. If Metro charges only the $2.00 base for that night, occupancy tax is $17.50 + $2.00 = $19.50 and the guest pays $24.38 + $19.50 = $43.88, or 17.55%. This is the guest's money, not your revenue, so underwrite revenue net of tax and price your public rate knowing the guest sees the total. You may not advertise that you will absorb or refund the tax (Section 5.12.080).

Tennessee Department of Revenue guidance (SUT-48) says that when a platform is required to collect sales tax, the host is not responsible for the tax on those bookings and does not report them. Marketplaces also collect and remit local occupancy tax on the bookings they handle. You or your manager still collect and remit on direct bookings and on any channel that does not collect for you, and Notice 17-24 says a management company that provides the lodging service registers and collects in place of the owner. Keep the platform's tax records, since you need to be able to show what was collected.

Direct-booking occupancy tax is due on the 20th, for the prior month's collections (Section 5.12.050). Filing on time lets you keep 2% as an accounting allowance. Late payments draw 8% annual interest and a 1% monthly penalty (Section 5.12.090), and each return's backup must be kept three years (Section 5.12.070), as our tax guide explains. Sales tax is filed through TNTAP, the state's online portal. Confirm account setup with Metro Collections and the Department of Revenue, and have a Tennessee CPA review how your bookings split between platforms and direct guests.

Taxes and licenses on the owner

Under SUT-48, business tax registration and a business license come once a county's or city's taxable gross receipts reach $100,000, with a minimal activity license for receipts from $3,000 up to that. Platforms never handle these. It also says LLCs and corporations can owe franchise and excise tax that sole proprietors and general partnerships do not, and that furniture bought from out-of-state sellers without Tennessee sales tax can create use tax.

Property tax is the other large fixed line. That turns on how the county Assessor of Property classifies the building and on the Metro rate for its service district, so confirm both with the assessor and the Metro Trustee. Use the seller's last bill as a check on your estimate, not as the answer.

Costs that come with the permit

Some operating costs exist only because of Metro's rules. A permit cost $313 per Metro's FAQ as of February 2026, 2.3% more by card, for a one-year term. At $313 a unit, 20 permits cost $6,260 a year before processing fees. Ask the zoning administrator for the current renewal fee. Each permit also requires $1 million of liability insurance, a responsible party in a 25-mile radius who is reachable at all hours, the permit number on listings, the guest limit and contact posted inside, and a six-month guest register.

Add the costs every rental building has: utilities, supplies, repairs, software and property management. Get the seller's actual operating statement for the past 12 months, line by line, and learn from the codes office and the Fire Marshal which inspections and life-safety work your building needs before permits can issue.

Reserves and the lines NOI leaves out

Net operating income is revenue minus operating expenses. It leaves out capital spending, loan payments and depreciation. That means the cost of replacing furniture, mattresses, appliances, roofs and mechanical systems never appears in NOI, and a buyer who forgets it overpays. Metro and the state publish no reserve figures, so we give no percentage. Set each reserve from the seller's dated list of capital work and a professional building inspection.

Hold four separate lines below NOI. The first is furnishings and linens, which wear out faster in a short-term rental than in a long-term one. The second is building systems. The third is a compliance buffer. Permits lapse after a year; Metro decides whether to take a renewal up to 30 days late and refuses it after documented complaints; three violations can mean revocation and a year's wait; unpermitted renting draws a $50 daily fine. Hold enough cash to carry a unit through a month without income. The fourth is a tax reserve, so that tax collected from guests is never spent as operating cash.

Stress tests before you bid

Run the model at least five ways. First, with only the units you can prove are permittable earning short-term income and the rest at long-term rent. Second, with the average rate falling by several times the 1.3% hotel decline of 2025, since Matthews counted 2,587 hotel rooms under construction in late 2025. Third, with weeknight occupancy cut and event nights held flat. Fourth, with the platform fee at 16%. Fifth, with one unit lost to a permit problem for a year. If the deal only works in the base case, it is not a deal.

Then value the NOI. Divide it by a capitalization rate, and compare that to what you would pay for the same income from a long-term building, because the permit risk belongs in the price. Rad Stay runs stays of every length, and it also sizes up Nashville buildings as possible purchases, leases or partnerships.

Questions

Does Nashville cap the short-term units in a single building?

Section 6.28.030, the land use table and the use standards contain none. Permits are per unit, with zoning, distance and any association or lease limits deciding which qualify. Confirm with Metro Codes.

Can I use the seller's revenue as my own?

Use it as evidence of demand only. A seller's permit never transfers, so you must qualify yourself under the rules of your application date.

Do Airbnb and Vrbo collect all the taxes on a booking?

Tennessee Department of Revenue guidance says they collect the sales and local occupancy taxes on bookings they process. You or your manager still collect on direct bookings and on channels that do not collect, and you keep the records.

What are the Nashville hotel benchmarks for 2025?

Per Visit Music City, which cites STR, county hotels ran 67.0% occupancy at a $199.20 rate, the rate down 1.3% and supply up 3.4%.

Should reserves be part of NOI?

No. NOI leaves out capital spending. Hold reserves as separate lines below NOI, sized from the seller's capital records and an inspection.

Sources

  1. Metro Code 6.28.030, Short term rental property permit, Municode (version of June 23, 2026)
  2. Metro Nashville Codes, Short term rental operation requirements (Wayback copy, Feb. 12, 2026)
  3. Metro Nashville Codes, Short term rental frequently asked questions (Wayback copy, Feb. 11, 2026)
  4. Metro Nashville open data, Residential Short Term Rental Permits, status Issued, retrieved Oct. 6, 2026
  5. Metro Code Chapter 5.12, Hotel occupancy privilege tax, Municode (version of June 23, 2026)
  6. Visit Music City, Research and Hospitality Stats (checked Oct. 19, 2026)
  7. Visit Music City, summer 2026 events release, July 28, 2026
  8. Matthews, Nashville Hospitality Market Report Q3 2025 (CoStar data), Nov. 7, 2025
  9. Tennessee Department of Revenue, SUT-48 Short-Term Rentals Reporting Requirements
  10. Tennessee Department of Revenue, Important Notice 17-24, Short-Term Rental of Vacation Lodging
  11. Tennessee Department of Revenue, Sales and Use Tax Due Dates and Tax Rates
  12. Airbnb Help Center, Airbnb service fees
  13. Tennessee Department of Revenue, Sales and Use Tax Notice 24-11, Change of Local Tax Rate: Davidson County (Dec. 2024)
  14. Tennessee Department of Revenue, Local Sales Tax Rates map, Davidson County transit surcharge note
  15. Metro Finance, Increase of Hotel Occupancy Tax, Metropolitan Nashville-Davidson County (June 14, 2023)
  16. Metro Finance, Short-Term Rental Tax return (510), taxes payable after July 1, 2023, line "Number of rooms rented per night x $2.50" (archived copy, October 22, 2026)
  17. Metro Council, BL2026-1493, passed Sept. 1, 2026, Mayor approved Sept. 4, 2026; Section 4 moves the 5.12.140 B date, Section 10 sets the effective date (Legistar)

Checked October 18, 2026.

Top image: Illustration of a representative scene, not a specific property.

To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.

More investment guides

All 4