Owner proposalGuest servicesAsk AI about Rad Stayoperations@rad-stay.com1-877-723-7829
1-877-723-7829 Get a proposalProposal
Acquisitions · Income, permits and property tax

How STR Properties Are Valued

A short-term rental building in Nashville is worth what a buyer believes it can earn after the sale, and that is often a different number from what it earns for you today. The permit stays behind when the deed changes hands, the county may tax the parcel as commercial, and comparable sales are thin. This page walks through how buyers, lenders and appraisers get to a number, so you can test any offer against your own math. Use it as background; the tax pieces belong with your CPA and the legal pieces with your attorney.

Key facts
Long-term multifamily cap rate, Nashville
5.8% in Q3 2026 (Lee & Associates, CoStar data)
Average sale price per apartment unit
$222,000 in Q3 2026 (same report)
Assessment ratio
25% residential, 40% commercial, 30% personal property
Property tax rate
$2.814 per $100 assessed, Urban Services District
STR permit at sale
Ends with the change in ownership; buyer reapplies
Bedrooms per permit
Four at most
On this page
  1. What a buyer is paying for
  2. The first test is whether a new permit can issue
  3. Net operating income for a nightly rental
  4. Cap rates and the long-term baseline
  5. Property tax classification moves the number
  6. The county's value and the market's value
  7. Comparable sales are thin
  8. Furniture, fixtures and equipment
  9. Records that hold up a price
  10. How Rad Stay looks at a property
  11. Questions
  12. Sources

What a buyer is paying for

A buyer of an operating short-term rental building gets three things at closing: the land and the building, the furniture and equipment inside, and a track record. Only the first two transfer cleanly. The track record lives in platform accounts, reviews and a Metro permit that names you, and none of those move to the buyer by deed.

Airbnb accounts do not change hands either; its help center says confirmed reservations remain tied to the seller's account. Metro Code 6.28.030 forbids assigning one; the moment the zoning administrator finds that title has moved, the seller's permit lapses and the buyer files again under the rules current on that date. A careful buyer therefore prices the building as it will exist the morning after closing: no permit, no listing, no bookings, and a fresh application ahead.

The first test is whether a new permit can issue

A serious buyer settles one question before touching the income figures: will Metro grant this parcel a fresh investor permit? Under section 6.28.030, fresh ones go only to parcels in certain mixed-use, office, commercial and shopping-center districts and in four Downtown Code subdistricts. The East Bank's DTC East subdistrict was left off. Residential zoning such as RS or RM is shut to new investor permits under Metro's permit-types page; a current holder may renew, though nothing passes to a buyer.

Two more screens follow. Distance is the second screen. Distance is taken between property lines. A park, church or school, or a day care center the state licenses, closer than 100 feet means no new investor permit can issue without a Council exception. Bedrooms are the third: one permit per unit, a four-bedroom ceiling, and no permit at all for a unit above that, per Metro's application page.

The state's 2018 Short-Term Rental Unit Act lets some older rentals stay under whatever local rule applied when they started. Its legacy section, and a July 2026 summary from MTAS at UT, both end that shelter when the deed changes hands by sale or transfer. So price the building as if that protection is gone the day the deed records, and ask your attorney whether it applies to your parcel at all.

If the answer to the permit question is no, the building is worth what it earns as long-term or mid-term housing, and the short-term history stops mattering to price.

Net operating income for a nightly rental

Investors start with net operating income, or NOI: a year of revenue minus the costs of running the property, before loan payments, depreciation and income tax. For a short-term rental the revenue line is what guests paid for stays, net of platform fees and refunds. Occupancy and sales taxes that you collect and send to the state and Metro are pass-through money and belong on neither side of the ledger.

The cost side runs heavier than an apartment's. Expect cleaning and laundry for every turnover, supplies, utilities and internet you pay instead of tenants, software, repairs and replacement of worn furnishings, management, property tax, and insurance. Codes also wants an insurance certificate with fire, hazard and liability coverage, the liability part at $1 million per occurrence or higher. Add the permit itself: Metro's investor-permit checklist listed a $313 fee in its November 2026 copy, and each unit renews every 365 days.

A buyer will rebuild your NOI from bank deposits and platform payout reports, not from a summary sheet. Twelve to twenty-four months of monthly detail lets them see seasonality, and a gap you cannot explain becomes a discount.

Cap rates and the long-term baseline

Price comes from dividing NOI by a cap rate, which is the annual cash yield an all-cash buyer demands. A lower rate means a higher price for the same income. Market reports such as the one below track apartment buildings, not short-term rental buildings, so buyers anchor on the apartment market and then decide how much extra return the added work and permit risk deserve.

Lee & Associates' Q3 2026 report on the Nashville multifamily market, built on CoStar data, puts the market cap rate at 5.8%, up from 5.6% a year earlier. The same report shows an average sale price of $222,000 per unit, vacancy of 9.2% and average asking rent of $1,638 a month.

Those figures give you a floor. If your units would rent for about that on twelve-month leases, the long-term value of the building is a number you can estimate today. A short-term premium exists only to the extent that short-stay NOI, after its heavier costs and higher risk, beats long-term NOI by enough to survive a higher cap rate. Run both versions before you talk to any buyer.

Property tax classification moves the number

State law sets the share of appraised value that gets taxed: 25% for homes, 40% for commercial and industrial parcels, 30% for business personal property, as the Metro Trustee lays out. Whether a rental building is residential or commercial for tax purposes changes its expense line and therefore its value.

Tenn. Code Ann. 67-5-801(b), as the state Comptroller explains it in Bulletin 2021-01, tells assessors to presume residential classification for a short-term rental only when the parcel is the owner's principal residence and holds no more than one rental unit, with room for one additional single-unit parcel if the owner lives there at least 14 days a year or 10% of the rented days, whichever is greater, and files an affidavit by September 1. When an assessor finds a short-term rental that does not meet those terms, the bulletin says it should be assessed commercially. A multi-unit building run for guests will not meet them.

Here is the arithmetic at the Urban Services District rate of $2.814 per $100 that the Trustee's page used in its October 2026 copy. A building appraised at $1,000,000 and classed residential is assessed at $250,000 and owes $7,035 a year. Classed commercial, it is assessed at $400,000 and owes $11,256. The $4,221 difference, divided by a 5.8% cap rate, is about $72,800 of value. A buyer will check your parcel's class on the Assessor's record and price in the higher figure if it applies. Have your CPA confirm the class and the bill for your own parcel.

The county's value and the market's value

Your tax appraisal is not a sale price. According to Assessor Vivian Wilhoite's office, the countywide 2025 values rest on 2024 sales and estimate an open-market price as of January 1, 2025. The Metro Council then sets the rate that turns that value into a bill.

Owners can appeal value, classification or both every year. For 2026 the Assessor's informal review deadline was 4:00 p.m. on Friday, April 17. If your parcel's class or value looks wrong, fix it on that schedule rather than during a sale, because a buyer underwrites the bill on the record.

Comparable sales are thin

Appraisers also look at what similar buildings sold for. Downtown loft buildings with a handful of units seldom trade, and when one does, the price blends land, furnishings and an operating business that a new owner might not reproduce. Appraisers often fall back on price per unit or per square foot from ordinary apartment and mixed-use sales and then adjust.

The cost approach, land value plus the cost to rebuild less depreciation, matters mostly for insurance and for newer buildings. For an older building on a small downtown lot, it rarely sets the price.

Furniture, fixtures and equipment

Beds, sofas, kitchenware, televisions and smart locks have value to a buyer who plans to keep operating, and little to one who will lease the units unfurnished. Some buyers list furniture separately in the contract, which can matter for the buyer's depreciation and for personal property tax. Ask the Assessor whether a tangible personal property schedule is due on the furnishings, and ask your CPA how to allocate the price.

An inventory with purchase dates and costs helps. A buyer who cannot tell a three-year-old mattress from a nine-year-old one will assume the worse case.

Records that hold up a price

With these in hand, you can compute both the short-term and long-term value of your building yourself and see where an offer lands between them.

  • Monthly payout reports from each platform and any direct-booking processor, matched to bank deposits
  • Operating expenses by month, with repairs kept apart from capital improvements
  • Permit number, issue date and expiry for every unit, and any complaint or violation history
  • Tax returns and payment confirmations for each unit's guest taxes
  • Insurance declarations showing the $1 million liability limit
  • The parcel's zoning district and the Assessor's classification
  • Bedroom count and floor plan for each unit
  • Furniture inventory with dates and costs

How Rad Stay looks at a property

Besides managing nightly, monthly and yearly rentals, Rad Stay reviews some buildings it may buy, lease or partner on. Each building gets its own look, and this page quotes no offer and no price. Before you accept any offer from anyone, get an independent appraisal from a Tennessee-licensed appraiser and have your CPA review the tax side of the sale.

Proof from a Rad Stay building

Union Street Lofts, four short-term rental lofts at 329 Union Street in the Printers Alley block, run by Rad Stay since 2023.

  • 4.98average rating across 214 Airbnb reviews of the four lofts
  • Guest Favoritebadges on the lofts' Airbnb listings, with Superhost status
  • 4 of 4lofts hold Metro non-owner-occupied permits, issued April 2023
  • WKRN News 2segment on the lofts, published June 11, 2026

Airbnb figures from the four listings as read October 4, 2026. Permits from Metro Codes. Read the case study · See the portfolio

Questions

Does my short-term rental income transfer to a buyer?

Not directly. A new owner starts without a permit and without the bookings, so the buyer applies again under current rules. A buyer values the income only as far as they believe they can rebuild it.

What cap rate should I use for my building?

Market reports track apartments, not short-term rental buildings. Lee & Associates reported a 5.8% market cap rate for Nashville apartments in Q3 2026, which is a reasonable floor for the long-term version of your building. Buyers usually want a higher return for short-stay risk.

Why is my rental building taxed as commercial?

The classification law, section 67-5-801(b), together with Comptroller Bulletin 2021-01, limits the residential presumption to owner-occupied parcels with no more than one rental unit, plus one qualifying additional parcel. Other short-term rentals should be assessed commercially, at 40% instead of 25%. You can appeal the classification each year through the Assessor; ask your CPA or attorney first.

Are platform payouts the same as NOI?

No. Payouts are revenue after platform fees. NOI subtracts cleaning, supplies, utilities, repairs, management, property tax, insurance and permit costs. A buyer works from NOI.

My parcel's zoning closes new investor permits. What then?

Then a buyer cannot replace your permit, and the building will be priced on long-term or mid-term income. Get Metro Codes to confirm both points for your lot first, and only then name a price.

To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.

More acquisitions

All 15