Owner proposalGuest servicesAsk AI about Rad Stayoperations@rad-stay.com1-877-723-7829
1-877-723-7829 Get a proposalProposal
Acquisitions · Storefronts below, rentals above

Mixed-Use Buildings Downtown

Picture a downtown Nashville building with a bar or boutique on the sidewalk and lofts overhead: one floor pays rent under a lease measured in years, the others earn from visitors measured in nights. When the owner thinks about selling, leasing or bringing in a partner, each stream is judged by its own rules, and downtown adds its own zoning code, historic overlays and an improvement district assessment. This page sets out what an owner of such a building decides and what to check first. It is general information; confirm legal and tax points with an attorney or CPA.

Key facts
Zoning
Downtown Code (DTC) subdistricts
New not-owner-occupied permits
Allowed with conditions in DTC North, South, West and Central
Issued STR permits, ZIP 37201
346, of which 338 not owner-occupied (Oct. 6, 2026)
Nashville retail vacancy
3.3% in Q3 2026 (Matthews)
Commercial assessment ratio
40% of appraised value
Central Business Improvement District
Annual assessment on private property since 1999
On this page
  1. What these buildings look like
  2. Downtown Code zoning and the permit test
  3. How many permits downtown holds
  4. Historic overlays add a second review
  5. Two income streams valued two ways
  6. Property tax and the improvement district
  7. Selling, leasing or partnering
  8. Conflicts between the floors
  9. Documents to gather first
  10. Questions
  11. Sources

What these buildings look like

Downtown's older commercial blocks, on streets such as Second Avenue, Printers Alley, Union Street and Broadway, often pair a storefront at sidewalk level with offices, storage or homes on the floors above, and some of those upper floors now hold nightly rentals.

Two examples show the pattern. On the Printers Alley block, the second floor of 329 Union Street holds Union Street Lofts, Units 201 to 204, run by Rad Stay; Metro issued each loft a separate investor permit in April 2023. And in December 2025, JLL announced it was marketing the Pilcher Building at 144 Second Avenue North, a five-story, 38,684-square-foot building from 1900, redeveloped in 2018, with three short-term rental lofts alongside office and retail tenants, zoned DTC.

Downtown Code zoning and the permit test

Downtown parcels are zoned under Metro's Downtown Code, split into subdistricts. For a building owner, the subdistrict name matters more than anything else on the zoning record. Four Downtown Code subdistricts appear on the 6.28.030 list of places where Codes still grants fresh investor permits, subject to conditions. DTC East, across the river, is not listed. A parcel with an NS suffix bars both permit types, and land under a Specific Plan follows what that plan allows.

Each loft upstairs still faces the countywide tests: a permit of its own, a four-bedroom ceiling, and the 100-foot spacing test. Council may lift the distance bar for a property through a resolution passed by 21 members after a hearing, and Legistar shows downtown buildings that won such votes: RS2024-580 exempted 55 units at 160 Second Avenue North in July 2024, and in September and October 2026 Council passed RS2026-2222, RS2026-2223 and RS2026-2293 for three units at 178 Second Avenue North.

How many permits downtown holds

In Metro's permit file as pulled on October 6, 2026, downtown's core ZIP, 37201, held 346 issued permits, with just 8 tied to an owner living on site. ZIP 37219 had 78, of which 75 were not owner-occupied. Next door, ZIP 37203 had 1,706, the most of any ZIP, of the county's 7,022.

Permit counts are not building counts. A single mixed-use building can hold three, four or dozens of permits, one for each unit, and a buyer will look up how many your building holds and when each expires.

Historic overlays add a second review

Several downtown blocks sit inside historic preservation zoning overlays. The Metro Historic Zoning Commission publishes separate design guidelines for the Broadway, Downtown and Second Avenue overlays. The commission's instructions add three points: a Codes building permit usually rides alongside the preservation permit; jobs on Second Avenue, Broadway and in the Downtown district may also go before MDHA and the design review panel set up under the Downtown Code; and staff sign-offs for work that meets the guidelines tend to come within four days.

The overlays regulate the building, not the rental. Chapter 17.36, where Metro's overlays live, says nothing about guest rentals in historic districts. What they change is the cost and timing of any renovation a buyer or partner plans, so a buyer will price that in. The commission's Historic Zoning Lookup map shows whether your lot falls inside one.

Two income streams valued two ways

The ground floor is usually valued like any commercial lease: rent, term, who pays taxes and upkeep, and the tenant's credit. Brokerage Matthews put Nashville retail vacancy at 3.3% for the July-to-September quarter of 2026; asking rent averaged a record $31.54 a foot, 5.6% above a year before, and downtown asking rents climbed 6.2%. A long lease at market rent with a solid tenant supports value; a short lease or below-market rent lowers it.

The upper floors are valued on what a buyer can earn after closing. If the units can be permitted again, a buyer weighs short-term income against its costs and risk. If not, the buyer values them as apartments. Lee & Associates put the Nashville multifamily cap rate at 5.8% in Q3 2026, which gives a reference point for the residential part.

Each permit ends with a change of ownership under section 6.28.030, so a buyer applies for every unit again. The commercial lease is a contract with its own terms on a sale of the building, so have your attorney read how yours binds a new owner; buyers usually ask the ground-floor tenant to confirm its lease terms in writing before closing.

Property tax and the improvement district

Expect the shop floor to be taxed on 40% of its appraised value, and expect the lofts to follow it, since the classification statute, 67-5-801(b), as Comptroller Bulletin 2021-01 reads it, keeps the residential presumption for guest rentals only where the owner lives on a one-unit parcel, plus one qualifying second parcel. A downtown mixed-use building with nightly rentals upstairs should plan on the commercial ratio for the whole parcel and ask its CPA to confirm. The Metro Trustee's page lists the Urban Services District rate at $2.814 per $100 of assessed value.

Downtown also has the Central Business Improvement District, Nashville's first, started in 1999 and run by the Nashville Downtown Partnership. Its services are paid for by annual assessments on privately owned property within its 549 acres, plus a 0.25% fee on certain retail transactions there. The partnership says the Gulch district is set to join in 2027. Look at your tax bill for the assessment line, because a buyer will.

Selling, leasing or partnering

A sale hands over both streams at once and ends every upstairs permit; the buyer reapplies. It suits an owner who wants out of both landlord jobs.

A lease of the upper floors to an operator keeps the deed and the permits with you, since the owner never changes. Metro lets an owner authorize someone else to run the units through a notarized form, and you keep the ground-floor lease as it is. The operator's guests and the ground-floor tenant then share entrances, trash and hours, so the two leases must agree.

A partnership can split the building's risk and upside. If title moves into a new entity, Metro treats that as a change in ownership, so structure and timing need an attorney who reads the permit rules first.

Conflicts between the floors

Noise, odors, deliveries and late hours from a bar or restaurant reach the units above. A tenant's lease may give it rights over signs, the sidewalk, trash space or the stair door that a rental operator needs. Before you sell, lease or partner, read the ground-floor lease for exclusives, use limits and access rights, and note any clause about residential neighbors.

Fire safety ties the floors together too. Once a property has three homes or more, the investor-permit checklist sends it to the Fire Marshal, and in these buildings the alarm panel, stair and exit doors may be shared with the shop. Keep the latest inspection report with the permit records.

Documents to gather first

Besides managing guest, monthly and annual rentals and commercial space, Rad Stay looks at certain downtown buildings as a possible buyer, tenant or co-owner. Every building is reviewed on its own merits, and nothing here states terms.

  • Deed, survey and the parcel's zoning and overlay record
  • Every commercial lease, with amendments, rent schedule and expiration dates
  • A rent roll for the upper floors and, for nightly units, each permit number and expiry
  • One to two years of income and costs, kept apart for the shop and the lofts
  • Recent tax bills showing classification and any district assessment
  • Fire Marshal inspection reports and any open violations
  • Insurance policies, with the liability limits for each permit
  • Records of any historic overlay approvals for past work
Proof from a Rad Stay building

Union Street Lofts, four short-term rental lofts at 329 Union Street in the Printers Alley block, run by Rad Stay since 2023.

  • 4.98average rating across 214 Airbnb reviews of the four lofts
  • Guest Favoritebadges on the lofts' Airbnb listings, with Superhost status
  • 4 of 4lofts hold Metro non-owner-occupied permits, issued April 2023
  • WKRN News 2segment on the lofts, published June 11, 2026

Airbnb figures from the four listings as read October 4, 2026. Permits from Metro Codes. Read the case study · See the portfolio

Questions

Will Metro permit each loft above my storefront?

Only if the parcel's subdistrict allows it and each unit meets the conditions: four bedrooms at most, the 100-foot test, insurance and inspection. Four downtown subdistricts accept new investor permits, and the East Bank's DTC East is the one left out.

Can a historic overlay stop nightly rentals upstairs?

No. Chapter 17.36 sets no guest-rental rule inside historic districts. What the overlay controls is outside work, such as signs, storefronts and windows, which goes through the commission before construction.

Do my ground-floor tenants' leases end if I sell?

Ask your attorney, because it turns on each lease's terms and Tennessee law. Buyers usually read every lease and ask tenants to confirm their terms in writing. The upstairs permits, by contrast, end with the change in ownership.

What is the Central Business Improvement District charge on my bill?

It is an annual assessment on privately owned property inside the district, which the Nashville Downtown Partnership uses for clean and safe services, economic development and marketing. Check your bill for the amount.

Can I lease the lofts to an operator and keep the shop lease?

Yes, that is a common structure. You keep the deed and the permits, authorize the operator through Metro's notarized form, and make sure the two leases agree on hours, access and trash.

Sources

  1. Metro Code chapter 6.28, section 6.28.030, Municode (current through June 23, 2026)
  2. Metro Code chapter 17.36, overlay districts, Municode
  3. Metro Nashville Residential Short Term Rental Permits (open data), status Issued, retrieved Oct. 6, 2026
  4. Metro Historic Zoning Commission, District Boundaries and Design Guidelines (Wayback copy, March 8, 2025)
  5. Metro Historic Zoning Commission, Apply for Historic Preservation Permit (Wayback copy, Oct. 22, 2026)
  6. JLL Capital Markets, Pilcher Building sale announcement (Dec. 16, 2025)
  7. Matthews, Nashville retail market report Q3 2026
  8. Lee & Associates, Q3 2026 Nashville multifamily market overview (CoStar data)
  9. Tennessee Comptroller, Bulletin 2021-01 on Tenn. Code Ann. 67-5-801(b), classification of short-term rental parcels
  10. Metro Trustee, How to Figure Your Property Tax Bill (Wayback copy, Oct. 22, 2026)
  11. Nashville Downtown Partnership, Central Business Improvement District
  12. Metro Codes, Not-owner-occupied permit checklist (Wayback copy, Nov. 5, 2026)
  13. Metro Codes, Apply for a Short Term Rental Property Permit (Wayback copy, Nov. 5, 2026)
  14. Metro Council Legistar, RS2024-580, distance exemption for 55 units at 160 2nd Ave. N., passed July 2, 2024
  15. Metro Council Legistar, RS2026-2293, distance exemption for 178 Second Avenue North, Unit 205, passed Oct. 6, 2026 (RS2026-2222 and RS2026-2223 passed Sept. 1, 2026 for Units 103 and 305)
  16. Metro Codes, Short Term Rental operation requirements, ownership change to a trust or LLC (Wayback copy, Feb. 12, 2026)

Checked November 12, 2026.

To keep this page, print it or choose Save as PDF in your browser's print window. The printout keeps the sources and the date.

More acquisitions

All 15